I was wondering whether we are really responsible for what
we do.Are we really doer of the deeds we do? At first glance the answer is
obvious,yes.But if we delve a little deeper we come to a somewhat different
conclusion.We do what our brain or mind tells us to do.Our actions are results
of our thoughts. But what we think is a result of the combination of factors
for which we are not responsible.The first factor is our genes,with which we
are made up of. What our brain cells are made up of depend on these genes.And
the brain directs us to do what we do at a certain point of time.Now we are not
the manufacturers of our genes.We are not responsible for it.We inherit from
our parents,they again from their parents and so on.In effect this chain goes back to the creation of life
which is again dependent on some cosmic forces about which we are not sure .
Our thoughts are also dependent on our education and
experience.We learn things at first which we are forced to ,starting from
uttering the first meaningful word which are tought by others .We go to school
and read books etc. which we are given to us to read.We study some things because either we are forced to do it by
others or we like those (which is again dependent on our genes and previous
experience).So basically all our education is a chance happening.
So also our experiences. At every moment of life something
is happening around us,in this earth and more generally in this universe.Each
incidence directly or indirectly affects our experience. A friend comes,tells
you something and that may alter your thinking drastically.Even those who are
by chance reading this article may begin to think very differently afterwards.
This changed thinking will change your way of action. In the next moment some
brick may fall over your head which may alter your actions radically. This is a
chance happening which causes your actions.If you consider carefully everything is a chance happening,from your
birth to death. The sperm which entered
the egg of your mother’s womb was a chance happening (which is
responsible for your genes).You marry someone you chanced to meet and it
changed your life.So is everything else.
So we can say what we do at a particlar moment is a chance
happening ( because it is dependent on the three factors,namely our
genes,experience and education which are all chance happenings).
We can go even deeper. The way we look ,the way our body and
health are, are all dependent again on what our genes are and what we do ( like
whether we exercise or not,whether we take such and such drugs, whether we got some disease for some
reason) and our experience ( we look diffrently at different times according to
our moods or whether one has a deep scar on his face as a result of chance
happening.)
Who am I? One would probably say I am a summation of how I
look, I behave and and I do at a certain point of time .Whatever I said before
suggests that all these factors are chance happenings and I am not responsible
for them.In fact this word I seems to lose it’s value.Because when I say I am
doing this we are actually referring to
a chance happening.Actually I can not pinpoint what I am, whether it is my eyes
or nose or any physical attribute or my behaviour or my deeds.And nothing is
controlled by this so called I.All are chance factors at a certain point of
time.
So we cannot really define I.
darun
ReplyDeletekharap na
ReplyDeleteHan Duluda, porlam. I fully agree what you said. Kintu amar mone hoy ei search ta thekei manusher adhyatmik aniubhutir suru hoy. amader ei nasshar jibaner uddeshyai Ami ke , setake jana. It is beyond mere Chance Happening.
ReplyDeleteExactly Dipayan..life is a journey to know oneself and the cosmos dwells in oneself.. I just tried to point out that that the ego about I is pointless what we call I cannot be really pinpointed.
Delete